logo
David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan | Source: Getty Images
David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan | Source: Getty Images

DC Fans Slam ‘Insulting’ New ‘Superman’ Casting: ‘That’s Like Great Value’s Superman’

Darin Bonso
Jun 28, 2023
06:15 A.M.

The new era for James Gunn's "Superman" officially began with a new face portraying Clark Kent and Lois Lane. However, supporters of the franchise expressed their displeasure with the new cast.

Advertisement

After a long search, James Gunn and co-chief Peter Safran ultimately found their new Superman/Clark Kent in David Corenswet and Lois Lane in Rachel Brosnahan to headline "Superman: Legacy." The hunt concluded after filming screen tests over the weekend of June 17, with Gunn confirming the news in a tweet.

Henry Cavill attends "The Witcher": A Netflix Original Series Panel during 2019 Comic-Con International at San Diego Convention Center on July 19, 2019 in San Diego, California | Source: Getty Images

Henry Cavill attends "The Witcher": A Netflix Original Series Panel during 2019 Comic-Con International at San Diego Convention Center on July 19, 2019 in San Diego, California | Source: Getty Images

Nicholas Hoult and Tom Brittney reportedly contended for the leading role, while Emma Mackey and Phoebe Dynevor vied for the role of "Daily Planet" reporter Lane.

Corenswet is set to be the fourth actor to don the cape on the big screen, following Christopher Reeve in 1978's "Superman," Brandon Routh in Bryan Singer's "Superman Returns," and Henry Cavill in Zack Snyder's "Man of Steel."

Advertisement
David Corenswet attends the screening of "Marriage Story" during AFI FEST 2019 presented by Audi at TCL Chinese Theatre on November 21, 2019 in Hollywood, California | Source: Getty Images

David Corenswet attends the screening of "Marriage Story" during AFI FEST 2019 presented by Audi at TCL Chinese Theatre on November 21, 2019 in Hollywood, California | Source: Getty Images

However, fans were skeptical about the casting. One Facebook user opined, "I have no great love for Superman, but if they have no plans to involve Cavill, and just got a younger replacement that looks like him, that's insulting and makes me care even less about this film."

Another DC enthusiast quipped, "That's like Great Value Superman." At the same time, someone else posted, "Rachel is the perfect Lois Lane, but Cavill, IMO, is the only one fit to wear the cape worn to perfection by Chris Reeve. Period!"

Advertisement
Fans' comments on the new "Superman" casting | Source: facebook.com/entertainmentweekly

Fans' comments on the new "Superman" casting | Source: facebook.com/entertainmentweekly

Yet, a few fans were willing to keep an open mind. "He has the look, she isn't conventionally pretty and neither was Margot Kidder, so let's give them both a chance," one fan remarked, while another hoped Corenswet and Brosnahan wouldn't regret joining the DC universe.

Gunn and Safran's franchise takeover caused a stir when they officially parted ways with Cavill in December 2022, contrary to earlier reports of his return. Insiders divulged that the pair allegedly looked for a younger face, leading to Cavill's exit.

Advertisement
A fan commented on the new "Superman" casting | Source: facebook.com/entertainmentweekly

A fan commented on the new "Superman" casting | Source: facebook.com/entertainmentweekly

"Superman: Legacy" is set to start filming next year and is scheduled for a theatrical release on July 11, 2025.

Subscribe to Suit Your Target on Google News!

Advertisement
Advertisement
Related posts
Twin Falls In-N-Out Burger | Source: Facebook/Deandre Smith

The Second Bystander Who Stepped In at Twin Falls In-N-Out Was Described in Just Three Words

August 03, 2026

James Haven and Angelina Jolie | Source: Getty Images

Angelina Jolie's Brother Comes Out as Gay after Years Away from the Spotlight — His Story & Photos

August 07, 2026

Mitch McConnell | Source: Getty Images

Mitch McConnell's Health Update Comes as Emergency Dispatch Records Detail the Morning of His Hospitalization

July 06, 2026

Senator Mitch McConnell | Source: Getty Images

Senator Mitch McConnell Seen on a Stretcher in Ambulance Video — Witnesses Detail What They Noticed About His Feet

July 11, 2026

Kai Trump | Source: Getty Images

Kai Trump, 19, Turns Heads in a Gold Gown at the 2026 ESPY Awards — and Her Walk Has Everyone Talking

July 17, 2026

L-R Skyblu, Redfoo, and Lauren Bennett | Source: Getty Images

Lauren Bennett of 'Party Rock Anthem' Fame Passed Away — Her Partner Has Not Spoken Since

July 07, 2026

Spencer Long and his family | Wendi Long | Source: Facebook/katrina.g.long | Facebook/wendi.long.39

Mother of Provo Fire Captain Who Lost His Entire Family Speaks Out — Details

July 22, 2026

Bonnie Tyler | Source: Getty Images

Bonnie Tyler's Family Shares Heartbreaking News After Singer's Sudden Death in Portugal — What Led to This Moment

July 09, 2026

Catherine, Princess of Wales | Source: Getty Images

Princess of Wales Arrives at Wimbledon in a Blue Gabriela Hearst Suit — but It's What She Did Before Entering the Club That Has People Talking — Photos

July 03, 2026

Jessica Lashly | Jersey and Justin Greer | Source: Facebook/Chad Mira FOX 2

Twin Sister Remembers Missouri Teen and Mom Killed at Their Missouri Home

August 07, 2026

The Long family | Source: Facebook/summitsmedspa

One Daughter Is Left Behind After Fire Captain, Wife, and 3 Sons Die in Heartbreaking Family Tragedy

July 21, 2026